Showing posts with label p2p. Show all posts
Showing posts with label p2p. Show all posts

Monday, September 15, 2008

Best Buy Buys Napster...Why?

The big news today is that Best Buy in the U.S. has purchased online music download company Napster for a reported US$121 million. Which begs the question: why?

Online music downloading has been an arguably struggling business for years, plagued by illegal, peer-to-peer (P2P) music Websites and customer's (warranted) hatred of silly things like DRM that prevent you from listening to purchased tracks on various devices, or burning them to CD. According to the Financial Times, Napster actually reported a loss of US$16.5 million in the year ending March 31.

Along with the still existent P2P activity and DRM (which is slowly melting away, but could see a resurgence thanks to the Government's Bill C-61), online digital download sites like Napster still have to fight the leader in that realm: iTunes. And with the iPhone added to the iPod family, iTunes will likely continue to be the leader of the pack, likely by an even bigger gap.

I'm trying to fathom why Best Buy would take on the task of competing with iTunes. The only thing I can come up with is that the strategy works in tandem with the retailer's recent move to ramp up its involvement in the mobile phone arena. Best Buy is opening standalone Best Buy Mobile stores that sell mobile phones. As is evidenced by devices like the iPhone, Nokia N95, and Sony Ericsson Walkman phones, music is becoming a huge part of the mobile phone experience. Could Best Buy be working out deals with carriers to link Napster downloading with their services? Or is Best Buy just looking to get back into this side of the business now that companies are offering DRM-free tunes that are more appealing to customers?

On the portable media player side, perhaps this is a way for Best Buy to make money on the sale of devices other than the iPod. Maybe a Napster subscription will be offered as an incentive to the purchase of an MP3 player. Or on the flip side, maybe "deals" on music downloading will be awarded in store on purchases. Who knows.

While there's no official comment on how the takeover might affect the Canadian market, my guess is that Best Buy is just testing the waters for now, and making sure that the company is well equipped to compete should digital music downloading take a significant upsurge in the next few years. While I'm rooting for this to take off, I'm not holding my breath either.

Bookmark and Share

Monday, May 5, 2008

Music File Sharers: 1, RIAA: 0


In the continuing battle to shut down illegal peer-to-peer music sharing Websites, the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), which represents the U.S. recording industry, has been dealt a blow. The District Court of Arizona has ruled in the case of Atlantic vs. Howell that simply keeping music in a "shared" folder on one's PC doesn't constitute illegal file sharing. In addition, the court called the act of downloading content from someone's PC "secondary copyright infringement" rather than "primary", since that person would be taking a copy of a copy, and not a copy of the original. Do you follow? The Court adds that the definition of "distribute" within the Copyright Act is not made clear enough to determine if simply making music available to others in itself can be considered "distributing" it.

At the end of its decision, the Court stated that it "is not unsympathetic to the difficulty that Internet file-sharing systems pose to owners of registered copyrights. Even so, it is not the position of this court to respond to new technological innovations by expanding the protections received by copyright holders beyond those found in the Copyright Act."

This makes sense. If someone steals something from me, how is it my fault? The owner of a stack of CDs in his car isn't considered at fault if a thief breaks in and steals them, even if he accidentally left the door unlocked. So why should someone be considered at fault if he fails to protect his PC hard drive, and others steal content from it?

It's true that, in some cases, people will purposely leave music in a "shared" folder in order to ramp up P2P site offerings. But in other cases, it could be an honest mistake. I'll bet that my parents make all their music available through a shared folder and don't even know it!

In this particular case, the Howells had over 4,000 music tracks available through the online P2P site KaZaA, many of which were digitally ripped copies of original recordings. However, although they admit to purposely sharing other content via KaZaA, they claim not to have intended to share the original recordings.

This could be a groundbreaking case in the issue of music distribution online and P2P sharing, which has plagued the music industry for years. Many artists have been taking the "if you can't beat 'em, join 'em" stance as of late, doing things like offering music tracks for free online in hopes of gaining consumer support. What's your stance on this issue?

Bookmark and Share

Friday, April 18, 2008

Bell Won't Back Down, Says Traffic Shaping a Must

A few weeks ago, the issue arose of Bell Canada engaging in Internet traffic "shaping" practices. Bell admits to purposely slowing down the Internet connection for heavy users of P2P and similar sites that are doing things like downloading full-length movies, and thus gobbling up a lot of bandwidth. Since then, there has been a flurry of commentary about the topic. Should Bell be able to shape or "throttle" its traffic? Should the use of P2P and torrent sites be considered "abuse" of Bell's unlimited plans?

The Canadian Association of Internet Providers (CAIP), which represents many small ISPs that use Bell's network to offer their services, sent a request to the CRTC for Bell to stop its shaping activities. The CAIP claims that Bell is "in breach of a number of regulated activites", and called the behaviour "anti-competitive interference in the activities of Internet users." Bell's response was a big fat "no". The telecommunications company feels that slowing down P2P and BitTorrent use is necessary in order to improve overall bandwidth performance for all users. Interestingly, when speaking to CBCNews.ca, Primus President Ted Chislett, who agrees with the CAIP, said that he doubts Bell has any congestion issues related to bandwidth at all.

Assuming issues of traffic congestion do exist as a result of heavy bandwidth usage, does Bell have the right to slow things down? After all, these customers pay the same monthly fees that everyone else does; they're just using the services more. The situation can be likened to an unlimited cell phone data plan: some users might send hundreds of e-mails per month, and chat on the phone for hundreds and hundreds of hours, while others might send a couple of e-mails here and there, and chat less frequently. They're both paying the same monthly fee, but what they get out of their packaged plan is up to them.

In fairness, trying to curb illegal activity is a good thing: if someone is using up gross amounts of bandwidth to acquire loads and loads of illegal content, then really, who are they to complain about slow speeds? But it looks as though P2P and BitTorrent sites can, and are, also used for legitimate activities. Take CBC's recent experimental move, for example, to offer the TV show Canada's Next Great Prime Minister as a free download through BitTorrent. The CAIP reports that it took "thousands of fans" on Bell's network upwards of 11 hours to download the program versus the minutes it should have taken. If more and more legitimate content like this CBC show becomes available via BitTorrent and P2P sites, will Bell stop its traffic shaping activity?

Either way, this issue has initiated a well-needed discussion about regulation and control of the Internet, and opened people's eyes to the rapidly growing nature of the Web world as a whole. We have so much bandwidth, and people will only continue to want to use more of it, not less. Should those who are making frequent use of faster speeds, and thus justifying continued progress in this area, be punished for doing so? Or, on the contrary, are heavy bandwidth users just abusing the capabilities of the service, and ruining the experience for everyone else?

Bookmark and Share